Invoice Fraud: How Criminals Modify PDFs to Steal Money

Invoice fraud is one of the fastest-growing cybercrimes targeting businesses today. According to the FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, business email compromise (BEC) attacks — which often involve modified invoice PDFs — resulted in losses exceeding $2.7 billion in 2022 alone. These attacks are sophisticated, targeted, and devastatingly effective.

The attack vector is deceptively simple: criminals intercept legitimate invoices, modify the PDF to change bank account details, and send the fraudulent version to unsuspecting accounts payable departments. The result? Payments intended for legitimate vendors end up in criminal bank accounts, often never to be recovered.

This article will explain how invoice fraud works, the techniques criminals use to modify PDFs, real-world examples, and most importantly — how to protect your business.

The Rising Threat of Invoice Fraud

Invoice fraud is not a new crime, but digital PDF manipulation has made it dramatically more effective and harder to detect. The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners reports that invoice fraud accounts for approximately 5% of all organizational revenue lost to fraud annually.

Why PDF-Based Invoice Fraud Is So Effective

• Trust in PDFs: Businesses trust PDF invoices because they look official
• Easy to modify: PDF editing tools make it simple to change bank details
• Hard to detect: Modifications can be nearly invisible
• Fast execution: Attacks can happen in hours, leaving little time for verification
• High success rate: Many businesses lack verification processes

As Hoxhunt explains, the combination of social engineering and PDF manipulation creates a perfect storm for fraudsters.

How Invoice Fraud Works: The Anatomy of an Attack

Understanding how invoice fraud attacks unfold helps you recognize and prevent them. Most attacks follow a similar pattern:

Stage 1: Reconnaissance

Criminals research their targets:

• Identify vendors and suppliers
• Learn payment processes and schedules
• Map organizational structure
• Find email addresses and communication patterns

Stage 2: Email Compromise

Attackers gain access to email accounts through:

• Phishing: Tricking employees into revealing credentials
• Credential stuffing: Using leaked passwords
• Malware: Installing keyloggers or email-forwarding malware
• Account takeover: Compromising vendor email accounts

Stage 3: Interception and Modification

Once inside email systems, criminals:

1. Monitor for legitimate invoices
2. Intercept invoices before they reach accounts payable
3. Modify PDF bank account details
4. Forward modified invoices to targets

Stage 4: Social Engineering

To ensure payment, attackers often:

• Create urgency ("Payment overdue, please process immediately")
• Mimic vendor communication style
• Use compromised email accounts for authenticity
• Provide "updated" banking information

Stage 5: Payment and Disappearance

After payment is made:

• Funds are quickly transferred through multiple accounts
• Criminal accounts are closed
• Evidence is destroyed
• Recovery becomes nearly impossible

As Veridion notes, the entire attack can happen in 24-48 hours, leaving little time for detection.

Real-World Examples of Invoice Fraud

Case Study 1: The Vendor Impersonation Attack

A mid-size manufacturing company received an invoice from a regular supplier. The invoice looked identical to previous invoices — same format, same logo, same invoice number. The only difference was a new bank account number listed in the payment instructions.

The accounts payable clerk, trusting the familiar format, processed the payment. Three days later, the real vendor called asking why payment had not been received. By then, $47,000 had been transferred through multiple accounts and was unrecoverable.

What happened: Criminals intercepted the vendor's email, modified the PDF invoice to change bank details, and forwarded it from the compromised account.

Case Study 2: The Urgent Payment Scam

A construction company received an urgent email from a subcontractor requesting immediate payment for work completed. The email included a PDF invoice with modified bank details, claiming the company had "switched banks" and needed payment to a new account.

The urgency and familiar sender led to immediate payment processing. The $125,000 payment was lost before anyone verified the bank account change.

What happened: Social engineering created urgency, and the modified PDF looked legitimate enough to bypass verification.

Case Study 3: The Multi-Vendor Attack

A sophisticated criminal group targeted multiple vendors of a large corporation. Over three months, they intercepted and modified invoices from six different suppliers, redirecting payments totaling $890,000 to criminal accounts.

What happened: The attackers compromised multiple vendor email accounts and systematically modified invoices, making detection harder because the attacks appeared unrelated.

These examples illustrate the variety and sophistication of invoice fraud attacks. As Coupa explains, no business is immune, regardless of size or industry.

How Criminals Modify PDF Invoices

Understanding the technical methods criminals use helps you detect fraudulent invoices.

Common PDF Editing Tools Used

Criminals use readily available tools to modify invoices:

• Adobe Acrobat Pro: Professional PDF editing software
• Foxit PhantomPDF: Alternative PDF editor
• Online PDF editors: Web-based tools that require no installation
• PDF manipulation libraries: Programmatic editing for bulk attacks

What Criminals Typically Change

Bank account information:

• Account numbers
• Routing numbers
• Bank names
• SWIFT codes (for international payments)

Payment details:

• Payment amounts (sometimes increased)
• Payment due dates (creating false urgency)
• Payment methods

Contact information:

• Email addresses for payment inquiries
• Phone numbers
• Mailing addresses

Techniques to Hide Modifications

Sophisticated attackers use techniques to make modifications harder to detect:

• Metadata manipulation: Changing creation dates to match original invoices
• Font matching: Using identical fonts to maintain visual consistency
• Format preservation: Keeping exact formatting and layout
• Incremental updates: Using PDF's incremental update feature to hide changes

As Tipalti reports, these techniques can make fraudulent invoices nearly indistinguishable from legitimate ones.

Red Flags: Signs of Invoice Fraud

While fraudulent invoices can look convincing, there are warning signs to watch for:

Email Red Flags

• Slight email address variations: vendor@company.com vs vendor@cornpany.com
• Urgent payment requests: Pressure to pay immediately
• Unusual timing: Invoices arriving at unexpected times
• Changed communication style: Different tone or formatting
• New email addresses: Vendors suddenly using different accounts

PDF Red Flags

• Modified metadata: Creation dates that do not match expectations
• Bank account changes: New account numbers without prior notice
• Visual inconsistencies: Fonts, spacing, or formatting that looks off
• Missing digital signatures: Previously signed invoices now unsigned
• Invalid signatures: Digital signatures that fail verification

Payment Red Flags

• Account number changes: Vendors requesting payment to new accounts
• Increased amounts: Invoices higher than expected
• Duplicate invoices: Same invoice number with different details
• Unusual payment methods: Requests for wire transfers instead of checks

As Finbite explains, recognizing these red flags early can prevent fraud losses.

Prevention Strategies: Protecting Your Business

Preventing invoice fraud requires a multi-layered approach combining technology, processes, and employee training.

1. Verification Callbacks

Always verify bank account changes through independent channels:

• Call vendors using known phone numbers (not numbers from emails)
• Use multiple verification methods (phone + email confirmation)
• Require written authorization for account changes
• Verify with multiple contacts at vendor organizations

Best practice: Maintain a vendor contact database separate from email communications.

2. Two-Person Approval Process

Implement dual approval for:

• All payments above a threshold amount
• First-time payments to new vendors
• Payments to changed bank accounts
• Urgent payment requests

This creates a checkpoint that catches fraudulent invoices.

3. PDF Verification Tools

Use automated PDF verification to detect modifications:

• Verify every invoice PDF before processing payment
• Check for modification indicators automatically
• Flag suspicious documents for manual review
• Maintain verification records for audit purposes

HTPBE detects PDF modifications that human review might miss. Upload any invoice PDF and get instant analysis showing whether bank details or other content has been modified — free, with no signup required.

4. Vendor Management

Establish secure vendor communication:

• Maintain vendor master files with verified contact information
• Use secure portals for invoice submission when possible
• Establish preferred payment methods and require authorization for changes
• Regular vendor audits to verify account information

5. Employee Training

Educate your team about invoice fraud:

• Recognize red flags in emails and invoices
• Follow verification procedures consistently
• Report suspicious activity immediately
• Understand social engineering tactics

6. Email Security

Protect email accounts from compromise:

• Multi-factor authentication for all email accounts
• Email security training to prevent phishing
• Email monitoring for suspicious forwarding rules
• Regular password changes and security audits

As Ramp notes, email security is the first line of defense against invoice fraud.

7. Payment Controls

Implement payment controls:

• Payment limits requiring additional approval
• Payment delays for new or changed accounts
• Positive pay systems matching checks to invoices
• Regular reconciliation to catch unauthorized payments

What to Do If You Suspect Fraud

If you discover a fraudulent invoice or suspect fraud:

Immediate Actions

1. Stop payment: If payment has not been processed, halt it immediately
2. Contact your bank: If payment was made, notify your bank to attempt recovery
3. Document everything: Save emails, invoices, and all related communications
4. Notify law enforcement: File reports with FBI IC3 and local authorities
5. Contact the vendor: Verify the invoice directly with the vendor

Investigation Steps

1. Review email headers: Check for signs of email compromise
2. Verify PDF authenticity: Use PDF verification tools to confirm modifications
3. Trace the attack: Identify how the fraud occurred
4. Assess damage: Determine financial impact
5. Review processes: Identify gaps in your prevention measures

Recovery Options

• Bank recovery: Work with your bank to attempt fund recovery
• Insurance claims: Check if your cyber insurance covers invoice fraud
• Legal action: Consult legal counsel about recovery options
• Vendor responsibility: Determine if vendor security failures contributed

As SearchInform explains, quick action improves recovery chances, though full recovery is often difficult.

Building a Fraud-Resistant Accounts Payable Process

A robust accounts payable process should include:

Pre-Payment Verification Checklist

• Verify invoice PDF has not been modified
• Confirm bank account matches vendor records
• Verify invoice amount against purchase orders
• Check invoice number against previous invoices
• Confirm vendor contact information
• Validate payment timing and urgency
• Require approval for account changes
• Maintain audit trail of all verifications

Technology Solutions

• PDF verification tools: Automatically check invoices for modifications
• Vendor management systems: Centralized vendor information
• Payment automation: Controlled payment processing
• Email security: Advanced threat protection
• Audit logging: Complete records of all activities

Process Improvements

• Segregation of duties: Separate invoice receipt from payment approval
• Regular audits: Periodic review of payment processes
• Vendor communication: Secure channels for sensitive information
• Incident response: Plan for fraud detection and response

The Cost of Invoice Fraud

Understanding the full cost of invoice fraud helps justify prevention investments:

Direct Financial Losses

• Stolen funds (often unrecoverable)
• Bank fees and recovery costs
• Legal expenses
• Investigation costs

Indirect Costs

• Operational disruption
• Reputation damage
• Vendor relationship strain
• Increased insurance premiums
• Regulatory compliance issues

Long-Term Impact

• Process changes and training
• Technology investments
• Ongoing monitoring costs
• Loss of business opportunities

Conclusion

Invoice fraud through PDF modification is a serious and growing threat. Criminals use sophisticated techniques to create fraudulent invoices that look legitimate, making detection challenging without proper verification processes.

The key to protection is a multi-layered approach:

• Technology: Automated PDF verification tools
• Processes: Verification callbacks and approval workflows
• Training: Employee awareness and education
• Vigilance: Recognizing red flags and suspicious patterns

Remember: a few minutes spent verifying an invoice can prevent devastating financial losses. When in doubt, verify through independent channels before processing payment.

Verify invoices before payment — Check PDF authenticity free at HTPBE